Mean Girls Unpacked: Analyzing Female-to-Female Office Bullying

Meangirls

Every woman with a corporate American job has encountered this rattlesnake in high heels. She is cold or overly critical to certain female colleagues, or worse, both. She engages in gossip and triangulation. She thrives on other women’s tears and sleepless nights that she causes. She won’t just do her job and go home, and refuses to let other women do the same. Because she is addicted to drama like some are to Starbucks. She and others like her exhibit the flipside of toxic masculinity.

They are the office mean girls.

It’s a shame that we are disgusted with bullying, and have a zero-tolerance attitude about it with children in school. But for some reason, it’s still alive and well in the office. And this is not to say that men don’t bully. They do. We have all heard of – or worked for – the “abusive genius” or “brilliant jerk.” But their abuse is rarely laid like a hunter does a trap, with cunning stealth. The abusive genius dumps abuse on a victim, like a bucket of cold water in the form of tantrums. He yells when disappointed, uses nasty language, or barks orders. In contrast, the mean girl is patient enough to wait a day or two, or even weeks later to do her dirty deed to others. And her dirty deed is elaborate. Raven (not her real name) is currently in this situation with her department, and is frantically looking for another job. “I work in accounting,” she says, “and some of the other women I work with have gone so far as to remove checks I put in the outgoing mail basket, hide them, then put them back in a few days later, so they will get mailed out late. Then I get blamed for vendors getting paid late. Sometimes, they have scrambled my account file folders’ order, so it’s difficult for me to find them. I can’t prove it, but I know it’s those evil women. I take the mail to the box myself and keep my files locked in a cabinet now.”

So what’s up with these she-wolves in sheep clothing? Why do they do what they do? Let’s dive deep into the black hearts of these women.

Imagined competition. Many women in the office see other women as teammates, sisters in the same boat who are fighting against the glass ceiling. Others, the mean girls afflicted with this issue, see other women as threats. In her mind, there cannot be two women who place first in the pageant. There is only room for one. This hell-on-heels will do whatever she can to ensure that everyone remembers that she is the best “[wo]man for the job.” She more than likely only hangs out with male employees. That’s not a problem, but what is the problem is how she treats other female employees. She is stingy with praise to other deserving women, criticizing them to the moon and back to management, or ignores them altogether. It creates tension and negative interpersonal relationships. Both create a hostile work environment.

Let’s peel back her mentality onion one more layer. Perhaps she feels being in the “boy’s club” will keep her safe. And the way to do that is to engage in the same belittling and sexist behavior some men in the office do. If she treats other women as second-class citizens, she will win favor with the guys who go to strip clubs for lunch or the male executive who calls his female assistant “sweetheart.”

What to do if you encounter this Leviathan in lipstick? She’s the toughest nut to crack, unfortunately, but it’s not impossible. Give her what you want: kindness. Does she do something really well? Compliment her. It might work. It might not. But perhaps she only needs to see that other women in the office are not the enemy, that they don’t want to steal her thunder.

Envy. This nasty, green-eyed monster hatches out of its egg in junior high, and some women are a minion (it’s not little, yellow, and cute) to it forever. Since they spend most of their lives in the office, other female colleagues suffer from this insecure hot mess’s complex. They don’t like the way they look, and will target any woman in the office who they feel is one degree more attractive. Said mean girl makes snide remarks about other women’s hair, clothes, and makeup to others in the office, or sometimes to the women themselves. I once had a female manager who was loyal to boxy men’s sweaters and corduroy pants, eye my bell-sleeve top one day and tell me with a sneer, “You look like some kind of hippy in that blouse.”

There really is no way to fix a relationship with this water moccasin in mascara. You may have to tell her to back off, or else you will go to HR.

Capturing the queen bee crown. This female with fangs suffers from the same dynamic the envious mean girl does: deep down inside, she has self-esteem down around her ankles. Her backstory is that she didn’t get validated early in life. This either happened in her home or among peers. She envied the prom queen and the cheerleaders, and any other females’ accomplishments she felt she couldn’t obtain. This mean girl was powerless to do anything about it as a girl, but as an adult, she will claim her queen bee crown, and everybody else better watch out! This is also the queen of triangulation. She recruits others to bully and mistreat other female employees. She will do things like spearhead lunch dates with a group but make sure certain women don’t get invitations. Said mean girl may also withhold important information from her targets, so they can’t do their jobs effectively. This is no accident; other women’s failings and faults are fodder for her to justify abuse to her posse. She will claim, “this is why we don’t hang with Allison. She’s so incompetent.” The excluded becomes the excluder.

What to do about said bear in high-heeled boots? Confront her. This is the kind of mean girl who wilts a little when you confront her directly about her cattiness. Ask her pointblank, “Have I done something to you? Because if I did, I’d like to know what, so we can clear the air.” Say something like this after every indignity she hurls, and the undesired behavior will more than likely stop. If this mean girl is relentless, resort to keeping notes, taking screen shots, etc. then get management and HR involved.

As mentioned above, many women enjoy a sisterhood in the office. Some women can be a challenge to work with, but with this crash psychology course, perhaps you can obtain civility or get coping mechanisms, and in turn contribute to the well-oiled corporate machine, stress-free.

What’s your thinking on this issue? How did or do you ladies deal with mean girls in the office? I open the floor to you.

Sean C. Wright is the author of 7 books. For more information about her writing skills and how she can assist you with yours–business or consumer–visit https://seanarchy.wordpress.com.

14 thoughts on “Mean Girls Unpacked: Analyzing Female-to-Female Office Bullying

  1. Ann Malley says:

    Reblogged this on Ann Malley and commented:
    Okay, so I blogged about crafting the perfect hero yesterday. Yeah. But, while I don’t want to bombard you, heroes without villains often fall flat. In fact, they do. With nothing to fight against, even Thor would end with a flabby sword arm and a rerun of old tales to tell. (Heaven forfend!)

    Enter Sean C. Wright, multi-published and absolutely in touch with the mean-girl villain that often strikes outside the office. Extended family anyone?

    Check out the details on your next villain–because girls can be just as cutthroat. The sweet smiles and lipstick aren’t fooling anyone. (And thank you Sean for this timely blog. LOVE it!)

    Write ON.

  2. MeetRhey | Self-Help Blogger says:

    another thing i think i learned about having conflict with another woman, one of my co-workers told me “Never take it personally even if it is directed towards you” meaning that there are times when their bullying and such are just misguided and misplaced. don’t necessarily just sit back and let it go (unless if is really juvenile). but deal with it in a professional manner.

  3. Tessa Barrie says:

    Great piece and spot on! I have worked with many of these ‘she-wolves in sheep clothing’ during the course of my working life. ‘Rattlesnake in high heels’ is another great description you use. Look forward to reading more of your blog.

  4. Author Gemma Dupont says:

    Yes, it all begins with school bullies. I believe that if we could irradicate bullying at an early age then we could irradicate it at work. I encountered this in nursing and midwifery. I think this is wonderful that you write about this, it needs to be publicized. Thank you for writing this.

    • seanarchy says:

      I accept children doing it to some degree because they don’t know any better. But there’s no excuse for grown women to do this, so I thought, I’m going to call them out. Ha!

      Seriously, glad I wrote an article you enjoyed. Have a terrific week!

  5. Dragthepen says:

    Love this post. In my first novel, The Waiting Game, I wrote about the mean girls that I first encountered in church. Yes, of all places mean girls go to church
    Great post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s